New Mortgage Rules….what will the impact be?
Financial Update, creditIf you ask me, the new mortgage rules will have an affect on a minority of the country. The ones that it will affect the most, will probably make the most noise. However; that hasn’t been my experience so far! Sure, it’s only been two days since the announcement, but there is already a stigma attached to the sudden announcement. Since the announcement on Monday morning (Jan. 17th, 2011), the majority of people that I have talked to are concerned NOT for the changes themselves, but the message that it sends to us as a country.
“Dad is grounding us and placing our piggy banks on the top shelf where we can’t reach them. Maybe when we grow up we can have our piggy banks back and act responsibly with our money”.
Ok, maybe a little harsh - but for the most part I think that’s how it’s resonating with a lot of people. In case you’ve missed the announcement - here are the changes coming into effect March 17th, 2011:
1.) Government insured mortgages will experience a shortened amortization period. Currently the maximum amortization period obtainable is 35 yrs. It is being shortened to 30 yrs. maximum.
2.) Government insured refinances: Currently you can refinance up to 90% of the value of your home. We will soon be allowed up to a maximum of 85% of the value of your home.
3.) No more government insured Home Equity Lines of Credit. Right now, some banks are offering up to 90% of the value of your home, on a line of credit. It will soon be a maximum of 80%. (Note: Most lenders moved this back to 80% a year ago already, so this almost becomes a moot point.)
And already, some homeowners are feeling like they’re getting picked on a little bit with the whole “obnoxious national debt level awareness”. I mean, yes - MOST homeowners in Canada carry a debt on their home…and we call that a mortgage. The mortgage is placed on an asset that, as history would prove, is a growing asset over time. Are the Canadians who were/are responsible enough to get themselves into a home to make a better life for themselves, being punished?
Here’s the problem: Over a very short period of time, more than a few of us went rushing in to refinance our homes and maxed our debt levels so we could go and play with some mad money. CHEAP money.
Another problem: We had lenders, yes government insured, positioned to sound the trumpets of ease of qualification and cheap money. Who wouldn’t consider it? It made sense at the time, right?
I have to say: I agree with a lot of the changes that have happened over the course of the last 2 years. Responsible lending will in turn produce responsible borrowing. As for the decrease in amortization, maybe there was another way to skin this cat? What about pulling back on debt-service ratio maximums to where there were before? I don’t know how many of us remember when the increase in debt-service ratio’s came about (maybe 5 years ago or so?)
Let’s just say that as we make changes, we look more and more like the olden days…which really wasn’t all that bad! Remember, we as a country only ever heard of government insured amortization periods OVER 25years about 5 years ago. It’s been THAT short of a period of time. Am I calling 5 years ago “the olden days”? Kinda, yeah! But as we re-position our guidelines, we’ll find that we don’t have other economic factors re-positioning back to support with these new rules. Things like incomes, inflation, and housing market values will prove to not work in conjunction with these new changes in pockets of some homeowners or buyers…granted.
Time will tell what the full impact will be on us Canadians with these new rule changes, but again - I really don’t think there’s going to too much to talk about here. There are many survivors that walk amongst us who lived through the era with less of an allowance on debt-service ratios, minimum 5% down payment, and a maximum 25 year amortization period.
Let’s leave with a question. By immediately going after the home owner sitting on an asset, are our sights zeroed completely on the right targets? What about the banks that offer credit cards?
CREDIT CARDS!
C-R-E-D-I-T C-A-R-D-S!!
That’s perhaps a topic of a new conversation…but really - how can Dad help us put this on the top shelf where we can’t reach it?
Sincerely,
Dan Mass
dan@canadafirstmortgage.com